Cheers@Home Winter 2026 | Pairings

GOING BEYOND BEER WITH PIZZA

Pizza and beer is often the default pairing, but cocktails, bitters and wine can make a great match as well. Don Antonio, an award-winning pizzeria in New York, is out to prove that pizza is far more affable with other beverages than diners may think.

The Midtown destination recently revamped its drink menu, recommending pairings that highlight their Neapolitan pies. For example, “with pizza with cured meats or stronger cheeses, we suggest structure: a Piedirosso or Aglianico wine from Campania, or a balanced Whisky Sour,” says Matteo Bassani, co-owner and beverage director.

“The wine brings enough body and acidity to stand up to the salt and fat, while the cocktail adds brightness and sweetness.”

Being a Neapolitan pizzeria, pizza always comes first. “This style of pizza has balance in terms of quantity of ingredients and flavors, so we’re not trying to create something complicated,” Bassani says.

“Always thinking about our Italian roots, we need to complement one of the ingredients, bring freshness or clean your palate. When the pairing works, you take a sip and you want another bite right away.”

Here are a few of Bassani’s pizza pairing suggestions.

MARGHERITA PIZZA With a margherita pie, Bassani likes to keep the drink fresh, bright and slightly bitter, such as a Spritz-style cocktail with an Italian aperitivo. “Having the drink a bit bitter and sparkling is good to refresh the palate,” he says.

But he cautions against going too complex. “Tomato, mozzarella and basil are already a perfect combination that the cocktail should

support,” Bassani notes. “That’s the same direction we follow on our menu with Margherita and Marinara pizzas.”

WHITE PIZZA “For a white pizza, I love a Martini-style cocktail,” Bassani says. “Something based on gin and dry vermouth, with herbal and aromatic notes given by the gin.” Without tomato sauce, white pizzas can feel richer, he adds. “So a dry, aromatic cocktail cuts through that richness, but the botanicals also complement ingredients like mozzarella and other cheeses.”

VEGETABLE PIZZA With vegetables, Bassani usually looks for something fresh and not too sweet. “A Mule-style cocktail can be great with a spirit such as gin or even Scotch, combined with citrus, ginger and maybe an herbal Italian amaro, since we always use an Italian product in our drinks,” he explains. “You can apply the same pairing to wine: minerality and freshness with vegetables.”

MEAT PIZZA With prosciutto, sausage, salame or meat-lovers pizzas, you can have fun, Bassani says. “An Old Fashioned or Boulevardier-style cocktail

works very well. Whiskey, vermouth, bitters and even an Italian amaro, of course, as our twist on our drinks.”

Meat gives you fat and saltiness, so the cocktail needs enough structure to stand next to it, he adds. “For spicy meats like ’ nduja from Calabria, I also really like the combination of tequila or mezcal. We use both examples in our current menu.”

ANCHOVY PIZZA “Anchovies are savory and already very intense, so I want the cocktail to do almost the opposite,” says Bassani. “Something refreshing, like a Mule or a simple gin or tequila drink with citrus and soda.”

Citrus and ginger help clean the palate. “With anchovies, I always want the drink to make the next bite taste even better,” he notes. “It’s the same reason we tend to pair anchovies with crisp, mineral whites on our wine list.” •